29 July, 2013

Review: Finnikin of The Rock



Rating:





Is it legal to marry a book?  

If not, is anyone here immoral enough to see to it that that happens? I promise you, the relationship I have with Finnikin of The Rock is serious. We're in love (even if the book doesn't know it). I am currently thinking about grabbing the book, strutting it in front of all the other books in my shelf and saying.. "guys, this is how it's done."

Because guys? THIS is how it's done.

Here's the thing, a few months back, I didn't care about how good an author's writing is. As long as they could get the story across, I was happy. Then, I read Daughter of Smoke and Bone, and was reminded just how much the beauty of words can make me love a book. And then.. Marchetta came along. 20 pages into the book, and I already know why people worship her so much in the YA community. She's a brilliant, brilliant writer.

I love High Fantasy, but lately, I've had somewhat sour experiences with the genre. Just to get across how much I loved this book (as if I hadn't already), I'll compare it with said experiences. The last fantasy books I read were Shadow and Bone, and Seraphina. I was lukewarm about both, which sucks, because I expect nothing less than a blown mind when it comes to fantasy.

You see, my biggest problem with Shadow and Bone was how simplistic, and "okay" the writing was. Finnikin ain't got none of that, my friend. With Seraphina, my biggest problem was how disconnected I was with the characters. Again, Finnkin of The Rock comes out clean.

I could feel the struggle of Finnkin, and I got so attached to the story, I might suffer from a terrible book hangover. Can we talk about the relationships in this book for a second? Finnikin's relationship with his father was filled with so much respect and love. I don't know if there's such a thing, but Marchetta pins down the "manly" love a father and son share. It didn't feel awkward or sappy. Actually, Marchetta pulls off writing from a male perspective so well. Everything from needing to prove himself as a man, to how he reflects his feelings for Evanjalin was done perfectly.

Oh.. Evanjalin. She's a weird character, I'll give you that. For a good portion of the book, I wasn't sure what to think of her. Then she started showing intelligence and elegance in the way she talks, that it was hard not to like her. She was manipulative too, and some people had trouble with that, but I love manipulative characters. (Also, her name's pretty cool.)

I always have trouble recommending fantasy books to everyone, even if it's as good as this book, because fantasy, especially high fantasy, is not for everyone. I'm not saying that because it's complex, but because they tend to have so many elements thrown in and some people get bored by that. But if there was ever a chance you want to give High Fantasy a try, for the love of coffee, let it be this one. Once you get past the very first few pages, things start to get interesting really quickly.

Another thing that I liked about this book, is that is reflects the era it is in, without excluding the  goriness and ... inappropriateness? Nothing irked me more with Seraphina than how everything was "pure", especially that it too, was in a medieval setting. Now I understand this is YA, and I shouldn't be expecting George R. R. Martin action, but I still liked how Marchetta doesn't shy away from writing a dialogue between men with all the dirty jokes that come with it, and the thoughts that go through a guy of Finnikin's age.  The 10 year old in me was happy.

This was a roller coaster of feelings. From a witty dialogue that had me genuinely laughing, to fast paced action scenes, and tragic ones that had me bawling like a kid.

Final words: The existence of this book makes me happy.

                        



Have you read this book? Then I want to know your thoughts about some shenanigins. Note: Do NOT click the button below unless you have read the book, because it might get a little spoilery.




16 comments:

  1. Can I be honest? The title and book cover just do not sell me on this book. And then, during your review, you said "for the love of coffee" and I hate coffee, so saying that makes me want to rebel against anything you say. But, I am curious about this one, especially if you think it's better than Smoke and Bone. Of course, I'd be afraid to read it and have you call me a homewrecker...

    ReplyDelete
  2. OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOH, dirty words!!!!!!!!!! hahahaha just kidding! Or not...


    I have had my eyes on this book for such a long time! Glad to know it's worth it. And now that you've praised Marchetta so much, I want to see what her writing style is like! Now I know which is going to be the first book I'll be ordering next month (just a few more days!!!).


    And I love that Evanjalin is manipulative <3 God, I love characters who know how to get what they want! And are you trying to say that there is a decent child/parent relationship in this book?! SOLD!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Well, dang. Looks like you and I had pretty different experiences with this book. I spent the entire time wondering why everyone is so enamoured with Marchetta's writing. I couldn't connect with any of the characters and I felt bored a lot of the time while reading this book. (Seraphina on the other hand? I fell in love with the writing and I adored Seraphina and the romantic interest.)

    After acquiring the audiobooks for the next two in this series, I decided to give it another try. I started listening to Froi of the Exiles yesterday and I was almost instantly reminded of why I disliked FotR. I just can't get into it. I'm less than an hour into the audio and trying to decide if I should force myself to finish it or not. :(


    Sorry, didn't mean to go on a rant there. I'm glad you were able to connect so well with this book! I wish I could have, too.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I bought this book a few months ago after reading reviews like this. I still haven't touched it, but I think I need to prioritize it!

    Mel@thedailyprophecy.

    ReplyDelete
  5. The name Finnikin I don't mind (sounds nice, really), but the cover I LOATHE! I totally agree. Marchetta is so unlucky with covers. Oh, and the design of the book pages is so simple, the design geek inside of me was in physical pain.

    And wait, what?! You don't like coffee? *gasp*. People like you are disappearing like the wind! HANG IN THERE ASTI!

    But seriously though, if you can get past the cover, and title and read this, I hope you love it :D

    ReplyDelete
  6. Glad to know your inner 10 year old is there ;)

    And yayayayayay! I hope you like this! (I'll be sitting biting my nails, because recommending books makes me nervous.)

    Actually, there are THREE decent parent/kid relationship. It just so... ugh.. the feels :(

    ReplyDelete
  7. Oooh, we seem to have totally opposite opinions here :P I liked Seraphina, but my biggest problem was with the writing. It just kept me distant. Or maybe it was my mood while reading the book. I don't know?

    Yeah, I'm really sorry you didn't like this. Some say the sequel is even better, but if you're not feeling it, then definitely put it aside.

    As to Marchetta's writing? The thing I liked was how effortlessly she gets the point across. I was writing a book while reading this, and the comparison just made me... ugh :P

    But I totally understand you not feeling this book. Some people felt the same. I guess with fantasy it's a hit or miss, huh? :D

    Thank you lots for stopping by kelley! :)

    ReplyDelete
  8. I hope you pick it up soon! Will wait for your review, Mel :)

    ReplyDelete
  9. "Then, I read Daughter of Smoke and Bone, and was reminded just how much the beauty of words can make me love a book. And then.. Marchetta came along. 20 pages into the book, and I already know why people worship her so much in the YA community. She's a brilliant, brilliant writer."
    Yes. The writing makes so much of a difference. It's actually why, if you are reading The Thief next, I hope it'll be a treat for you. And Marchetta's prose is just amazing. Hehehehe, I can't wait to read some more of it :).

    Sad that you weren't a huge fan of S&B or Seraphina. I too was a bit disconnected from the charas. (and medieval world--so many HFs in medieval inspired worlds) in Seraphina, but S&B I did love. It's nice, though, that you did find a high fantasy that you LOVED, even if this one involve book hangovers. (Aren't they best kind anyway?)

    Evanjalin sounds like my kind of character. Name and fierce attitude.

    "But if there was ever a chance you want to give High Fantasy a try, for the love of coffee, let it be this one."
    *Grins*. I guess I don't have to wait too long :).
    Hope you enjoy continuing the series! I hear Froi is the real heart of the chronicles--and woah! I just noticed that Kristin Cashore blurbed the book!! She never blurbs things!
    *jaw drops*
    *eagerness returns*

    ReplyDelete
  10. Yeah, I just read your reply on The Thief about Gen's perspective. I think I'm eager enough to get over my Finnikin hangover. I haven't had one of those in a loooooooong time!

    I didn't enjoy Seraphina, but S&B was entertaining. It's no Finnikin though :P

    Evanjilin was awesome! One of my favourite quotes were by her.

    I didn't notice Kashore blurbed the book! I want to read Graceling but am very hesitant :D

    ReplyDelete
  11. Oooh. I can't tell if you'd like Graceling. Even though, as soon as I saw that you were hesitant, I was like, hmmm... how shall I convince her to read it? It does feature another kickass female protagonist... why are you hesitant?

    ReplyDelete
  12. The reviews on my GR feed are all over the place :P I'm thinking about delaying ordering it this month and getting the third book in this series instead.

    Hmmm.. decisions decisions..

    ReplyDelete
  13. Same with Asti here, I didn't pick up Finnikin because of the pretty cover but because a fellow blogger was positively RAVING about the book so I read it and bam! I'm pretty much in love with half the supporting characters like Lucian, Trevanion, Beatriss... if you love Finnikin, I'm almost sure you'd enjoy Froi of the Exiles as well (but we never know so looking forward to your review of it)! :D

    ReplyDelete
  14. Ugh, every time I think about those characters I miss the book even more. Froi of the Exiles, arrive noow!! :/

    ReplyDelete
  15. I'm so glad you loved this book because Marchetta is a goddess. A GODDESS I SAY!

    ReplyDelete